Home » Technology Integration Facilitator » Currently Reading:

Student vs. Teacher created Media

January 18, 2008 Technology Integration Facilitator 2 Comments

While listening to the Technology Shopping cart podcast I heard Wes Fryer say:

I am a catalyst for creative engagement and collaborative learning [...] Students creating media and then students collaborating.

I fully agree with Wes that we don’t see students do this nearly enough in the traditional school system. They are still mostly the passive recipient of teacher created content and lectures. Even when students are supposed to “create”, it is often a directed and restricted creation. “First you need to do this, then that, then ….”. It goes back to allowing students time to “play”, which I wrote about in a post las month. They need that time to be creative.

What motivates anyone to create?

My personal experience is that I simply enjoy the process of creating. Let that be designing a website, writing a blog post, or knitting a sweater. Other reasons for creating “something” are financial benefits, the need or enjoyment of the final product.

So how can we motivate students to C R E A T E ? How do we motivate teachers to allow students to create?

I am looking around in my own elementary school and am observing the following:

The teachers who have caught the “tech bug” and are using tools to showcase student’s work. They are finding these tech tools useful for personal use as well. Ex. Taking digital images to document an activity, scanning in of students’ artwork, uploading photos to classroom blogs, having students type in a story or report in word or directly into the blog.

Some of the teachers have taken the next step and are using the available tools (hardware and web- based) to manipulate their own content, present curriculum related material found on the web, and students’ work to mash up and to CREATE new materials. They are are using them for reviews, personalization, and content delivery infused with technology. Ex. PowerPoint presentations with images, audio and video; Jeopardy style games; document cameras; teacher created lectures delivery through podcasts, using digital images taken from/by students to create new teacher presentation, etc.

The next natural step should now be “student creating media”. The one that Wes Fryer is talking about. Allowing students to learn through their own creations is still not widely acceptable (especially not when high stakes testing is looming). But isn’t that the way we learn?What creation is more desirable (student or teacher)? Is one above the other in hierarchy or just a stepping stone to the next level? What is the value of teacher created material?

If teacher created material for their students is the stepping stool for student created media, that it has its value! Then we need to motivate teachers to create, create, create for their students? Maybe that will help them see the value of the PROCESS of creating in their own learning.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Currently there are "2 comments" on this Article:

  1. Langwitches says:

    Miss Profe from “It’s a Hardknock Teacher’s Life” e-mailed the following comment (it somehow was seen as spam from the blog)

    Silvia, I whole-heartedly support both student and teacher created content.
    In fact, I am contemplating/struggling with ways to incorporate both into
    my Spanish classes. I say struggling, because I am doing it on my own,
    without much education and support from the Tech. dept. at my school. I
    blogged about this very topic on my own blog recently.

    For example, I want to create a blog for my level 2s, but I can’t quite
    envision how this would manifest itself in a Spanish class. I don’t want
    the blog to just be a repository of work I have assigned to students.

    Additionally, I have an iPod classic, purchased for me by the school.
    However, the operative word is one iPod. How do I make a go of this when I
    teach 10-15 students at a time? How do I promote the process of learning
    Spanish via student-created work with just one iPod?

    Silvia, if you have suggestions re: the utility of a class blog in a level
    2 Spanish class, and how to promote process of learning and student
    created projects via one iPod, I would really appreciate it.

    I anxiously await your reply.

  2. In my school we have both teacher- and student-created content. What I’ve noticed is that the teacher-created content isn’t really received any differently by the kids than traditional materials like textbooks. For the kids, it’s the process of creating the content (writing a book review podcast, creating a newsreel about the Berlin Olympics in 1936) that really charges them up.

    The hard part is that it’s a big leap for the teacher. Even for the teachers who are comfortable creating content, it’s a big risk to promote student-learning via content creating. And for me, a tech coordinator with 300 students, 40 faculty members and 50 computers to support, the time it takes to (a) assist the teacher in creating, managing and delivering the lesson and (b) assist the students in their content creation is daunting.

    But the payoff is tremendous.

Comment on this Article:

Subscribe to Langwitches

Archives

Choose a Category

In Need of Professional Development?

Contact
Silvia Rosenthal Tolisano for customized workshops, coaching and presentations.
Video Conference sessions available.

For a list of sample sessions visit Globally Connected Learning .

Langwitches on Twitter

Upcoming Conferences

Like Langwitches on Facebook

Visitor Maps

Digital Storytelling Tools for Educators

Guest Posts

Teaching English through Film and Screenwriting…

YouTube

I am honored to be able to cross-post Stephen Wilmarth’s blog post below on Langwitches. If you are interested to read more about Steve’s International Experimental program at the Number One Middle School in Wuhan, China take a look at: Take a Peek into China’s First 1:1 iPad Class Learning…Young …

(No Comments)

Guest Blogger- Heather Durnin On New Forms of School and Learning

Holocaust-Skype-Call

Heather Durning who blogs on Mrs. D’s Flight Plan has graciously allowed me to cross post her latest post here on Langwitches. I believe her blog post is invaluable as it fulfills the need to document, summarize and assess learning outcomes when leading your students with new forms of teaching …

(No Comments)

Sowing the Seeds for a More Creative Society

Fantastic Contraptions-1

I am thrilled to be publishing a guest post by Andrea Hernandez, cross posted from EdTechWorkshop Blog on Langwitches. In an earlier post, The Science of Play, I shared my ideas about the importance of playful learning, the type of learning observed in very young children. In my personal experience …

(No Comments)

Professional Development

Walking the Walk: Action Research

back-up-tak-with-action

I have been blogging for 6 years now… I have written extensively about blogging (131 posts categorized “blogging” on Langwitches) I have shared two guides for teachers to start blogging with their students “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part …

(3 Comments)

Learning About Blogs FOR your Students: Part VII – Quality

blogging rubric

This is Part VII in the series “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part II B: Student Writing Part III: Commenting Part IV: Connecting Part V: Reciprocating Part VI: Consistency Reading, responding, assessing and monitoring our students’ progress on their …

(22 Comments)

Learning About Blogs FOR your Students- Part VI: Consistency

consistency

This is Part VI in the series “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part II B: Student Writing Part III: Commenting Part IV: Connecting Part V: Reciprocating I have seen many teachers start blogs (professional and classroom ones), only to …

(7 Comments)

What am I Reading?

Silvia's bookshelf: currently-reading

Catching Up or Leading the Way: American Education in the Age of GlobalizationLost on Planet China: The Strange and True Story of One Man's Attempt to Understand the World's Most Mystifying Nation, or How He Became Comfortable Eating Live SquidThe World Is Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First CenturySECRETO BIEN GUARDADOThe Digital Diet: Todays Digital Tools in Small BytesFacebook Marketing: An Hour a Day

More of Silvia's books »
Silvia Tolisano's currently-reading book recommendations, reviews, quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists

21st Century Learning

The Digital Learning Farm and iPad Apps

iPadApps-DigitalLearningFarm

I previously published a chart of Bloom’s Taxonomy and iPad Apps, which I use regularly when planning projects or look to reinforce certain skills and literacies. Since I also rely heavily on The Digital Learning Farm concept (based on Alan November’s work), I felt it was time to create a …

(23 Comments)

Continuing to Learn with the iPad- Storytelling

5th graders-storykit

In an attempt to document the trials and errors of using a classroom set of 20 iPads in our K-8 school, I am adding a new post to the collection of iPads in the Classroom: Transliteracy- QR Codes and Art Working on iPad Fluency with Lower Elementary Students Step-by-Step: How …

(29 Comments)

Learning About Blogs FOR your Students: Part VII – Quality

blogging rubric

This is Part VII in the series “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part II B: Student Writing Part III: Commenting Part IV: Connecting Part V: Reciprocating Part VI: Consistency Reading, responding, assessing and monitoring our students’ progress on their …

(22 Comments)

The Digital Learning Farm in Action

The Digital Learning Farm and iPad Apps

iPadApps-DigitalLearningFarm

I previously published a chart of Bloom’s Taxonomy and iPad Apps, which I use regularly when planning projects or look to reinforce certain skills and literacies. Since I also rely heavily on The Digital Learning Farm concept (based on Alan November’s work), I felt it was time to create a …

(23 Comments)

Screencasting Apps for the iPad

Explain Everything

Teaching ourselves, our students and other educators how to use screenshooting (images) and screencasting (video) tools is a relevant skill to have that integrates in so many areas. Think Tutorial Designers (A role from the Digital Learning Farm) or the Flipped Classroom model. Being able to create, share and take …

(7 Comments)

The Teacher as a Conductor of an Orchestra

Slide14

Should Teachers Be More Like Conductors? This bog post from 2009 took me to the following TED talk by Itay Talgam. Although I am not a musician, nor listen to much classical music, I was mesmerized. This TED talk was geared towards organization leaders, but I so agree with Tania …

(4 Comments)

Global Education

Walking the Walk: Action Research

back-up-tak-with-action

I have been blogging for 6 years now… I have written extensively about blogging (131 posts categorized “blogging” on Langwitches) I have shared two guides for teachers to start blogging with their students “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part …

(3 Comments)

Curriculum21 Podcast Episode with Vicki Davis and Julie Lindsay

c21-podcast

I had the opportunity to speak to Vicki Davis and Julie Lindsay. Two educators who are making a difference in their students’ lives as well as thousands of other students and teachers from around the world. Vicki is a teacher from Camila Georgia. She blogs on the Coolcatteacher blog and …

(1 Comment)

TED Talk- Raghava KK: Shake up your story

Raghava KK- Shake up your story

  This is a short TED talk by Raghava KK, the illustrator of the iPad book POP-IT – Raghava KK Inc. This video is not a commercial about the artist’s iPad book though, but shares a message about the importance of raising our children with PERSPECTIVE. In his book, children …

(No Comments)

Blogging With your Classroom

Walking the Walk: Action Research

back-up-tak-with-action

I have been blogging for 6 years now… I have written extensively about blogging (131 posts categorized “blogging” on Langwitches) I have shared two guides for teachers to start blogging with their students “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part …

(3 Comments)

Learning About Blogs FOR your Students: Part VII – Quality

blogging rubric

This is Part VII in the series “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part II B: Student Writing Part III: Commenting Part IV: Connecting Part V: Reciprocating Part VI: Consistency Reading, responding, assessing and monitoring our students’ progress on their …

(22 Comments)

Learning About Blogs FOR your Students- Part VI: Consistency

consistency

This is Part VI in the series “Stepping it Up: Learning About Blogs FOR your Students” Part I: Reading Part II A: Writing Part II B: Student Writing Part III: Commenting Part IV: Connecting Part V: Reciprocating I have seen many teachers start blogs (professional and classroom ones), only to …

(7 Comments)

iPads

The Digital Learning Farm and iPad Apps

iPadApps-DigitalLearningFarm

I previously published a chart of Bloom’s Taxonomy and iPad Apps, which I use regularly when planning projects or look to reinforce certain skills and literacies. Since I also rely heavily on The Digital Learning Farm concept (based on Alan November’s work), I felt it was time to create a …

(23 Comments)

Continuing to Learn with the iPad- Storytelling

5th graders-storykit

In an attempt to document the trials and errors of using a classroom set of 20 iPads in our K-8 school, I am adding a new post to the collection of iPads in the Classroom: Transliteracy- QR Codes and Art Working on iPad Fluency with Lower Elementary Students Step-by-Step: How …

(29 Comments)

Transliteracy- QR Codes and Art

qr-code-jamie

Transliteracy is defined on Wikipedia as The ability to read, write and interact across a range of platforms, tools and media from signing and orality through handwriting, print, TV, radio and film, to digital social networks. The modern meaning of the term combines literacy with the prefix trans-, which means …

(11 Comments)

Digital Storytelling

Transliteracy- QR Codes and Art

qr-code-jamie

Transliteracy is defined on Wikipedia as The ability to read, write and interact across a range of platforms, tools and media from signing and orality through handwriting, print, TV, radio and film, to digital social networks. The modern meaning of the term combines literacy with the prefix trans-, which means …

(11 Comments)

Why and How to Participate in Teddy Bears Around The World Project?

TBAW-project

I posted a few weeks ago about the ongoing Teddy Bears Around the World (now in its fourth year) project. The project blog and hub can be be found at http://www.langwitches.org/blog/travel/teddybearsaroundtheworld/ I have created a How-to-Guide in order to articulate how and why to join such a project, to make …

(3 Comments)

Teaching English through Film and Screenwriting…

YouTube

I am honored to be able to cross-post Stephen Wilmarth’s blog post below on Langwitches. If you are interested to read more about Steve’s International Experimental program at the Number One Middle School in Wuhan, China take a look at: Take a Peek into China’s First 1:1 iPad Class Learning…Young …

(No Comments)