Digital Portfolios are so much more than a digital versions of a paper portfolio, a folder sent home at the end of the week, semester or year or an online version of someone’s writing journal. In addition, I am talking about Blogfolios, which are digital portfolios on a blogging platform. These blogfolios are:
- not behind a password protected wall to encourage authentic feedback and a global audience
- not only sharing the “best” work of someone, but the process of learning that it took to get to the “best” work in this moment in time
- the platform to allow open discussion to have one’s work be critiqued, influenced, re-mixed and built upon by others
If I had to create a “pitch” for Blogfolios, I would say:
Blogfolios are the glue that can hold it all together!
Blogfolios are a pedagogical tool/platform for the teacher to facilitate learning and at at the same time can become in critical component for a heutagogical (self-directed/ self-motivated) process for the learner. Blogfolios are the glue that can hold all curricular content, goals and objectives as well as support school initiatives, observations, assessment and accountability requirements or personal passions, interest and projects together… you can insert other education related programs, theories, taxonomies, methods, etc. and we can find connections HOW blogfolios could help support it.
Literacy
We know that the notion of literacy, reading and writing in order to communicate in our day and age has expanded from traditional reading and writing via text and analog paper sources. The world around us has significantly and is continuing to change exponentially. We read and need to comprehend multimedia messages, follow hyperlinked, non-linear content and need to be able to write on different platforms. We need to know how to take into consideration their collaborative and connected nature and a potential global audience. How do we take advantage of different media and platforms to effectively address copyright considerations and requirements, search engine algorithms and network characteristics to engage potential readers, collaborators, curators and thought partners? To be considered literate, we need skills beyond basic reading and writing and extend into the world of “reading and writing” in a networked, global and different types of media environment with the ability to not only consume information, but find, evaluate, analyze, curate, remix, and create new types of information.
…Blogfolios can be the platform to expose learners to the skills, dispositions and habits of mind to amplify basic reading and writing into the world of an extended notion of literacy. Blogfolios give learners the chance to not just hear about these new literacies, but they are actively experiencing and working with new skills to become fluent in them.
Heutagogy
Pedagogy is about the techniques, methods and strategies teachers use to facilitate learning for their students. Heutagogy is centered around self-motivated and self-directed learning. Webucation is about taking advantage of the fact that anyone with access to the internet and a device is capable to access information, tutorials, mentors, coaches, materials, videos, text, images in order to literally learn anything they wish to learn. The only thing that is required to bring is the MOTIVATION to learn the skills to find, evaluate and use what is available for their own learning. There is a shift away from learning for grades, credentials and other extrinsic factors towards learning for the desire to learn and intrinsic motivation.
… Blogfolios can support learning and teaching ourselves. Blogfolios should not belong to a particular teacher, professor or the school, but to the learners themselves. Taking ownership of their blogfolios is crucial versus having entries to the blogfolio be by assignments and deadlines only. Blogfolios are not strictly meant to be for “school work”, but should include documentation of any learning (in and outside of school).
Documenting Learning
Documenting our learning serves as a heutagogical tool. Capturing artifacts that demonstrate the process of learning as well as a product, need to be able to be stored, archived and displayed somewhere. Blogfolios give the self-directed learner a hub to document their learning and to make it visible for others. Where have they been? What steps did they take along the way? How are these learning artifacts connected with each other? Documentation OF learning can grown into documenting FOR learning and documenting AS learning, when strategically embedded into the learning process.
…A blogfolio allows for all types of media (text, images, video, audio) to be inserted and embeded into a post. Through linking of blog posts or individual artifacts, a timeline of the learning process can be created and reflected upon. When documentation happens over a period of time, the blog with its chronological postings facilitates a timeline of the learning process. The blogfolio becomes the showcase to use documentation FOR learning (our own as well as the learning of others who visit and engage in our blogfolio. When we use documentation as a vehicle of learning, the blogfolio becomes the tool and the process at the same time.
Reflection & Metacognition
Reflection is not an add-on to the learning process, but a critical component. Thinking about your thinking (metacognition) reflecting on one’s own cognitive processes and stresses the awareness and flow of our thinking as strategies to help us learn. We can, of course, reflect and think about our thinking in paper journals, in verbal conversations, in our own heads, but there is a depth to our learning added when we reflection in public and in writing (not only in text necessarily). Jackie Gerstein says “If we don’t create a process of reflecting and framing them, then we are leaving learning up to chance,”
…A blogfolio allows for the support of that framing of reflection and metacognition. Activities, projects, curriculum units, assessments, etc, don’t stand on their own, in isolation, but they become part of a process. How can I tell the story of my learning? What does my learning mean to me and to the world around me? Why is my work important and how is it related to other people and other work? How is it related to my own work from last week, from last month/year and to my other areas of interest? What are cross-curricular relationships, patterns? Where do trends in my knowledge, learning emerge?
Student (and Teacher) Led Conferences
Many schools are embracing student-led conference to give students a voice and ownership when reporting on their process and progress. Why should teachers and parents talk ABOUT the student? Why shouldn’t the student take ownership, know what the goals are, how to accomplish them and how to articulate the journey and process towards these goals. In addition, Andrea Hernandez asks why not teacher-led conferences as the next step to complement or replace teacher high-stakes, model lesson observations?
…A blogfolio allows for students and teachers (“the learners”) to collect and demonstrate over time their goals, process and growth towards these goals and other objectives. The ownership rests with the learner to present evidence of steps towards and accomplishments of their goals. The ownership of looking for this evidence does not lie with the teacher or supervisor.
Assessment
As educators, we are responsible to assess our students’ learning. We assess to fulfill requirements of accountability and we assess to tell us, as teachers, more about our students. We assess to know what our students know, what they have learned and how that will affect what we will and how to teach next.
…A blogfolio can give us insight HOW we and our students are learning (if properly framed to embed reflection and metacognition), not just WHAT was learned. We learn how students will use what they learned and apply it in authentic situations. We could replace weekly spelling tests of 10 random words or grammar quizzes and see how students are USING the assigned words and grammatical forms in authentic context in a blog post.
Differentiation
We don’t all learn the same way. We don’t all come with the same background content knowledge nor the same abilities and skills to make sense of the content we are presented with. In Wikipedia, differentiation is described as “a framework or philosophy for effective teaching that involves providing different students with different avenues to learning (often in the same classroom) in terms of: acquiring content; processing, constructing, or making sense of ideas; and developing teaching materials and assessment measures so that all students within a classroom can learn effectively, regardless of differences in ability.” John Spencer asks himself: What happens when students have choice in the way they learn and show evidence of their learning?
…A blogfolio supports choices for learners. Blogfolios are not prescribed, with a one-size-fits-all appearance, matching content, assignments, and media format. Learners are to take responsibility and creativity to show evidence of their learning. Ron Ritchard worries about how too much instructions can inhibit genuine thinking in students. Blogfolios are a platform and a framework that encourage learners to make their own thinking and learning visible on their own terms.
Project/Inquiry/Problem Based Learning
No matter if you are implementing project based, inquiry based or problem based learning with your students, all stress the importance of the thinking process and the cognitive awareness of the learner.
…A blogfolio supports that process of inquiry/project/problem based learning by encouraging documentation and reflection. The inherent chronological sequencing of a blogfolio adds to a timeline for unpacking content/learning/phases/results. The ability to hyperlink different posts/content and documentation artifacts on your blogfolio encourages the creation of connections on multiple levels. Blogfolios also strengthens the learner’s capacities to articulate, visualize and present their thinking, reasoning and decision making skills behind their work.
Digital Identity
Our Digital Identities are becoming increasingly more important in our
digital world! Our digital identity is our online that we claim in cyberspace. Digital identities are not reserved for companies or organizations, but are increasingly important for individuals as well. It is a fallacy to believe that, if we choose to NOT be online and worry about building and growing a digital identity consciously, that we do not have a digital identity. Not finding a digital footprint of a person online speaks volumes about the “lack of the work” that their are sharing and contributing to the field. Also, even though someone might choose not to create a digital footprint, others might/will for them. Will Richardson in his book “Why School?” challenges every school: “How can we make sure that every student who walks on graduation day is well Googled by his or her full name?”
…A blogfolio allows us and our students to build an academic digital footprint. It gives us the space to upload, store and archive our work to build content that will develop and become part of our footprint and seed, grow and maintain our digital footprint. Through blogfolios, we can take advantage of opportunities that develop skills to strengthen our identity, connect our content to an audience and become aware of the interconnections and flow of networks. Blogfolios give learners an opportunity to create (positive) content, attached to their name, that when someone googles them, they will be found among the search results. It becomes part of our digital identity to strategically be search engine friendly (keywords) and create content that will associate ourselves within a desired content area.
Accessibility
The traditional school system can be very rigid. There is a daily school schedule to follow that dictates us when to be in class and with a certain time for a specific subject area. Teachers and students are siloed within the school and from the outside world. Parents are dependent on phone calls or annual parent/teacher conferences to learn more about what is academically going on in the lives of their children. Teachers, who teach the same students, usually have no access and insight to the work and thinking of their students in other academic areas, unless they schedule specific meeting times with their colleagues. Professional Development opportunities offered at the school are scheduled for specific days and times and conferences or workshops are in different locations.
…A blogfolio removes many of the barriers to accessibility. Student blogfolios give parents and teachers a view of learning anytime and anywhere. Parents don’t have to wait until a teacher calls them or invites them to a conference meeting. They can review blogfolio entries with their child, deepening the conversation and going beyond the typical interaction of “What did you do in school?”… “Nothing”. Teachers will gain valuable insight into their current students’ thinking and learning outside of their own classrooms and times together as well as future students at the start of a new school year. When educators share their own thinking and learning, their experiences and best practices, blogfolios become a rich source of professional development for other educators around the world. No longer do we have to wait to go to a conference or workshop, but we are able to access new learning opportunities 24/7.
How do you see blogfolios as the glue that can hold all the puzzle pieces together? What are some of your puzzle pieces and how are/can blogfolios support them?
You’ve hit a homerun here Silvia!
After reading this post and reviewing the 2016 ISTE Standards for Students, educators will realize students sharing their learning with blogfolios references all six standards.
Not just for students, educators can reflect and share evidence of professional learning with a blogfolio. In short, an excellent strategy for learners everywhere!
Bob
Thank you Bob for checking the ISTE Standards and aligning them to the use of blogfolios as well. It just makes sense as a platform and as a pedagogy. 🙂
Hello Silvia,
This is such a thoughtful post! This is super clear!
I was wondering if you have any favourite platforms to blog?
I’ve started to use Seesaw with my students just the portfolios part for now. I like how students can access it via QR code.
Thanks
Magali
Magali,
Funny you should ask…I recently wrote a blog post comparing using WordPress and Seesaw as a blogflio (digital portfolio) platform, take a look- http://langwitches.org/blog/2016/07/28/digital-portfolios-blogs-vs-seesaw/
Sylvia, I think we could all benefit from seeing some examples of solid blogfolios… I can imagine them, but would love to share some with my own students. Help?? Thanks for the post – always thought-provoking and right on the money!
@Joy
You are right, good examples are important. Take a look at the following blog post, where I try to make blogging visible
Here is also my Diigo Group with student blogging exemplars–
Please share some of your best examples.
Hi Silvia,
It is great to hear about other people going down the digital portfolios or as you put it blogfolio road. You have made several interesting points about “why” they are important and how they document learning not an end product. I still find that often the audience is unclear to some teachers. Many feel that it is being done for the parents. Other teachers feel that it is for admin. However, we need to remember that it always comes back to the student and what is best for their learning. Thanks for the thoughtful information. Tricia Friedman wrote an interesting post on Blogging for Better Learning (http://list.ly/list/ZQ8-blogging-for-better-learning) which you might also find interesting.
I’ve recently been exposed to the idea of using blogfolios as an educational tool.
I really appreciated your insights, especially in regards to the reason behind using this medium. And to a large extent, that process of creating artifacts to document learning and using that as a scaffold to promote reflection seems beneficial.
As I explore more of these, the more value I see in the medium and the more compelling I see them. There are, however, a few questions, that I have about the use of the medium. Primarily, I’ve been thinking a bit about the communication and communal aspect of blogging. From my (limited) experiences blogging and following blogs, I find that there tends to be a gap between individual / groups of bloggers and the interaction isn’t quite as tight as I’d like. Within the context of pedagogy this is easily addressed – as a teacher is usually guiding a class, encouraging communication and shared work, assessing progress, and giving feedback. How can these benefits from a pedagogic system be extended to help heutagogical learning? Some of this seems to be helped by surrounding social media – such as the use of reddit, facebook, LinkedIn, or the like, as they help communities with a particular interest share such. To what extent, then, are there important social media skills to learn and build in developing solid heutagogic practices? More so, how can we encourage collaborations between creators?
Hi Noah, I think you’ve raised a very interesting question. It reminds me of something that I have often wondered myself. How important are comments on a blog? I think it comes down to the question: are you creating content for yourself or for an audience? Many well-written blogs I have encountered very often receive few comments, most of the time none at all. But their authors have kept at it for years. I would think that if the number of comments they receive is a primary motivating factor, they would have given up a long time ago. In the context of a blogfolio, which is a space for self-reflection and a way of documenting one’s work, I would actually discourage students from focusing too much on how many readers they get or how many comments they receive. I feel that that feeds into a narcissistic need to be patted on the back for whatever one does—a problem endemic to many social media platforms. If however, they are creating a blog for an audience, then engaging their readers in discussion can inform them of the sorts of content they should create. To help drive readership, telling other people about your blog on social media is one way, as you mentioned. Some other tips I got from this article called “Welcome to Blogademia”, include participating in discussion on other people’s blogs, linking their blogs to yours (and perhaps they will return the favor), and promoting certain blog posts at conferences.
Hi Jen,
That’s the dilemma of blogs, isn’t it? If you open up your work to a wide audience, you’re expecting to have comments.
I like your point : “I feel that that feeds into a narcissistic need to be patted on the back for whatever one does—a problem endemic to many social media platforms”.
However, I feel that comments became very interesting when they’re becoming a discussion as we do right now.
Thanks
Magali
Interesting. I do agree with the wariness of a potential narcissistic focus. But at a certain point, is sounds that you argue that a blog’s strength is precisely its ability to reach out to others and receive feedback. Otherwise, there’s not a large distinction between generating and curating artifacts in a private manner, akin to a private journal. There is certainly a benefit that exists solely in that, especially to enhance reflective and metacognitive clarity. But, if the intent is specifically to reach out, create accountable structures, and communal feedback, then how can we do so within the context of blogs that are primarily focused on one’s own learning?
In the context of the classroom, it makes a lot more sense since there is a direct community of learners who are engaging with the same topic. In addition, having a teacher to help hold learners accountable, track their progress, and provide ‘expert’ feedback can really help an individual progress in their learning. So, how can these principles translate to the ‘lifetime’ learning for which you seem to propose blogs are valuable?
My current thinking is that regardless of topic learned, one may always be able to find or form a small community to share with – to encourage an exchange of ideas, learning, and growth. With the breadth of the web, it’s not too inconceivable that other individuals interested in similar topics exist. And for me, the closest thing that matches this sort of flow and discussion is actually Reddit.
At the core, I think the difference that I care about is the distinction between what I view as an ‘online portfolio’ and an ‘online learning community’. I don’t have much against online portfolios, but such a system is purposefully designed for self-motivated individuals to share their expertise and skills (and perhaps to grow them). This gap, however, is very large for individuals who feel vulnerable, insecure, and otherwise may most benefit from positive social growth. So how can we build safe communities and venues for people to encourage their process of learning?
Hi Noah, I was wondering what you think about collective blogs. In practice, it would involve finding a group of like-minded individuals with the same learning goals and starting a blog together. Most of the interaction initially would be among members of this community, with them commenting on each other’s posts. Eventually, however, with the members’ combined network, the blog could potentially draw a bigger audience faster than an individual blog, allowing for an even richer exchange of ideas. And because it is a collective blog, members can support each other in the face of negative comments. That might work for the ‘vulnerable, insecure’ individual that you were speaking about. I know that collective blogs are being used in higher ed to encourage interaction and collaboration among learners. Outside of the higher ed context, though, I’m not sure if I know of any blog that works in the same way. Most of the collective blogs I come across are usually commercial in nature, and owners of the blog don’t comment on each other’s posts.
Jen,
I’ve given collective blogs some thought. I don’t have much experience or exposure to them, so I can’t really evaluate them honestly.
This, to some extent, though is where I get a bit more meta and transition from thinking about ‘community of learners’ to ‘(a) community of communities of learners’. In general, this would mean tools and resources that help individuals find communities, run them, have meaningful goals, and provide moderation support. A particular collective blog would represent a particular community of learners. And within the context of that particular community, that medium and methodology may be a good mechanism to share learnings. By itself, however, it could not support individuals who are looking to create or find such communities.
Notably, this would be distinct from a community of educational technologists, or educational researchers. And to some extent, I question whether a community at the ‘top’ is stable enough to provide the required structure and guidance, or whether this would be better supported by a service / product team of ‘experts’. The core idea, though, would be mechanisms and structures to frame and support a multitude of individual learning communities.
I’m currently evaluating e-portfolios. I realise you don’t mention those but do you know how these blogfolios differ from e-portfolios? I do know of a couple of other edtech researchers that reject e-portfolios in favour of their personal blog. I’m inclined to do that, myself.
It seems that though e-portfolios were designed for two purposes – academic and non-academic – they were used for academic purposes and seemed to fall short of their promise (lack of portability, wall gardens, etc).
The other purpose is the one I’m interested in, using them for forward planning and not just recording
I’m currently evaluating e-portfolios. I realise you don’t mention those but do you know how these blogfolios differ from e-portfolios? I do know of a couple of other edtech researchers that reject e-portfolios in favour of their personal blog. I’m inclined to do that, myself.
It seems that though e-portfolios were designed for two purposes – academic and non-academic – they were used for academic purposes and seemed to fall short of their promise (lack of portability, wall gardens, etc).
The other purpose is the one I’m interested in, using them for forward planning and not just recording